United Kingdom

The Scottish Government is “unlikely” to win the legal challenge of the second referendum

T:

he is a former civil servant who negotiated in 2014 Scottish: The independence vote says the Scottish Government is unlikely to win the legal challenge to the UK government in holding a second referendum.

Professor Ciaran Martin, who was the Constitutional Director Government Office From 2011 to 2014, he said that no court can impose The United Kingdom self-dissolved.

Speaking to the BBC’s The Nine on Wednesday, he said: “Even if, in my opinion, it is unlikely, the Scottish Government has succeeded in winning their case. “This is not the end of the matter for the British government.”

This week, Nicola Sturgeon wrote the plans for the renewed independence case with the release of a new set of documents.

Government of the United Kingdom The Unionist parties may say that we are not going to participate. They could say that we are not interested in the result of this false referendum. we will not promote independence

But: Boris Johnson He said he would not grant the Article 30 order needed to hold a second vote on the issue.

Professor Martin said the UK’s stalemate between the Scottish governments was “completely different” from the debate over the independence referendum a decade ago.

He said. The fundamental difference between today and a decade ago is that the British government at the time was ready not only to give up the referendum, but to think more about the collapse of the UK if the referendum were won by Yes.

“We are in a completely different situation now.”

It was assumed that the Scottish Government would pursue a second referendum without a Section 30 order.

Professor Martin added: “For example, there is no agreement; there will be no so-called Section 30 order, which was the same as it was a decade ago; the Scottish Government is passing its own bill, two things. It may happen.

“One is that the Supreme Court is blocking, in that case holding a referendum is illegal. The other thing is that there is a lot of speculation that this is the Scottish Government’s plan, there is a slightly weaker voice, it is about consulting with the people to give the Scottish Government a mandate, it may or may not pass. »

“The British government and the Union parties can say we will not run. They can say that we are not interested in the result of this false referendum. We are not going to promote independence. “

The Scottish Government is “unlikely” to win the legal challenge of the second referendum

SourceThe Scottish Government is “unlikely” to win the legal challenge of the second referendum

Back to top button