Despite more than 37,000 new cases a day, up 45 percent from the beginning of the month, hospitalization remained unchanged during that period, according to the CDC.
On Monday, a Florida District Court judge issued an injunction against the mandate, saying the agency could not issue a mask for travel. The judge appointed by Trump accepted the exception from the definition of masks as a sanitary uniform and said that the agency does not have the authority to require people to wear them.
The ordinance began with a cascade of announcements from airlines, public transit systems and other transport companies that they would stop using masks for passengers. Despite the survey This shows that the majority of Americans support the mask mandate on public transportation.
He also alarmed public health and legal experts, who fear this could reduce the agency’s power over public health decisions.
“So many people get sick with masks,” said Wendy Parmett, co-director of the faculty at the Center for Health Policy and Law at Northeastern University. “But it is not about that. It is about who sets our public health policy. Judiciary – 35-year-old elected judge – or the CDC and the Department of Health and Human Services?
The CDC said in a statement on Wednesday that it believed its mask rule was “legal” and “well within the CDC’s legal authority to protect public health.”
“It’s important that the CDC secures its authority to protect public health,” George Benjamin, executive director of the American Public Health Association, told POLITICO. “The judge’s decision is very poorly reasoned and simply wrong. It needs a more experienced legal review. “
The order remains in force for the time being. A department spokesman said the DOJ appealed to a Florida court Wednesday and may ask the court to suspend a judge’s order while the case is being heard.
Although the cases are over, Current assessment of the agency The Covid-19 community level is low in 94 percent of the country.
This fact has not escaped some critics of the agency’s relatively new policy, which defines risk using data entry series, including hospitalization rates and ICU bed availability, and not just case numbers.
There is “cognitive dissonance” at the CDC, which says the risk to most countries is low in defending its mandate, said Jonathan Rainer, a professor of medicine and surgery at George Washington University. “Well, what is it?” Is the risk low if the risk is significant enough for the masks to be on public transport? I think the risk is high and the order of the mask must be observed. ”
The CDC has said it will continue to “monitor public health” to determine if a mask mandate remains necessary and recommends that people continue to wear masks on domestic public transport.
This report was contributed by Josh Gerstein and Sarah Overmohle.
The DOJ will appeal the decision to mandate travel masks after the CDC says the masks are still needed on public transport
Source link The DOJ will appeal the decision to mandate travel masks after the CDC says the masks are still needed on public transport