Health

States impose 15-week abortion ban as right-wingers debate Roe’s next strategy

Their strategy underscores Conservatives’ belief that the Supreme Court will rule their way and limit or eliminate Vs. Rowe Wade At the end of this year, and many have concerns that Texas law may eventually be repealed as a result of ongoing legal challenges.

“States do not want to pass laws that they have to break. “They do not want pointless training.” “The foresight to do 15 weeks is clear now that the green light is likely for them.”

While they acknowledge political and legal obstacles, many in the anti-abortion movement say they are disappointed lawmakers are not following the Texas leadership.

“Some national and state groups believe we need to act cautiously and strategically,” said Christie Hamrick, a student for American Life, who is approving bills in dozens of states that reflect Texas and ban early abortion pills. Pregnancy. “We respectfully disagree.”

“We want to see less incrementalism,” he added. “This is the time to move on to victory.”

At the same time, abortion rights activists say they face many challenges: they probably do not have the votes to stop the progress of these bills, and they are struggling to persuade a mad and exhausted society to mobilize against policies that it does not pay attention to. And the outrage of Texas’s unique private enforcement scheme.

“These states often bring in copies of Texas taxes at the same time,” said Jessica Arons, ACLU’s chief policy officer, citing six-week Texas-style bans that were introduced in Arizona and Florida but have yet to move forward. “Once they finally get the 15-week bill, it allows them to put it as a reasonable compromise. “They move to the Overton window and come up with an idea of ​​what the reception center is.”

Florida Gov. Ron Desantis, who has indicated he intends to sign a 15-week abortion ban, which is expected to take place this week, told reporters in January that the bill was “very reasonable” and said “many people will be happy with it.” ”

West Virginia del Ruth Rowan called his 15-week legislation a “beginning” and a “good start.”

Arizona Sen. Nancy Barto told a Senate hearing last week that while she believes “every life should be saved,” 15 weeks is “the limit of common sense” and “a step in the right direction.”

Some leftists see a wave of 15-week bans as an attempt to force Democrat MPs to vote harder – as a poll has shown. More public support To restrict abortions after this period of pregnancy rather than the wider Texas-style legislation.

“The six-week ban has sparked outrage and protest. “So when they pull back with a 15-week ban, it flies a little bit more under the radar,” said Olivia Capello, who works on state policy battles with Planned Parenthood. “But any arbitrary restrictions on what you can and can not do with your body and what decisions you can make about pregnancy can have a devastating effect on the people and children they already have.”

The vast majority of abortions in the United States occur before 15 weeks – More than 90 percentAccording to federal data. But thousands of people terminate late pregnancies each year for a variety of reasons – from finding a fetal anomaly to saving money and arranging a trip for the procedure.

Most anti-abortion groups say they understand that Conservative lawmakers are going as far as they can, and see the 15-week ban as a major improvement allowed within 24 weeks. Vs. Rowe Wade.

“This legislation will save about 5,000 babies a year and so I’ll take these 5,000 babies and, if we were playing poker, I would say these 5,000 babies and you will raise them all,” the Florida Right said. Life president Linda Bell told POLITICO. “I really want to see us go further.”

Right-wing advocacy groups have long argued that it should be the states – not the federal government – that define abortion policies and say they welcome a future where, for example, Florida goes one way and Texas the other.

“A good mind may disagree on how to make the most of this opportunity, and every state is different,” said Suzanne Libel, director of state policy. “What is the composition of their chamber and senate?” Who is the governor? Who is going to be re-elected this year? It all goes together. “

Other right-wing groups concerned about drowning in costly legal battles are urging lawmakers to wait for the Supreme Court ruling and for states to know exactly what the law of the land will look like.

The anti-abortion group West Virginia for Life, for example, warns state lawmakers not to prohibit either a 15-week abortion ban or a Texas-style abortion ban this year, in a letter to state lawmakers Monday that said it was a “reasonable” wait.

“We have no idea what the Supreme Court will decide this year on abortion jurisprudence,” the group said.

Aside from questions about what the Supreme Court will allow, other experts fear that the privacy rights enshrined in nearly a dozen state constitutions could thwart attempts to ban abortion altogether or almost completely – a legal hurdle that has already blocked Montana bills. And may be enacted in Florida, Alaska and other GOP-controlled states seeking to restrict access to the procedure.

There is also concern among anti-abortion advocates that Texas law is so inconvenient that it could harm their cause.

In a January letter to lawmakers in various states weighing in on various types of abortion bans adopted by POLITICO, Texas Alliance Life Adviser Paul Linton wrote that “states should not enact their own versions of the Texas Senate Bill 8” before the Supreme Court ruling. The Mississippi law states that such bills “are more likely to alienate courts whose votes should be quashed.” Roe Rather than address them. “

Linton pointed to justice. Vocal discomfort On the consequences of a Texas private abortion enforcement mechanism – which critics have called a “bonnet hunter” or “vigilant” scheme – and argue that it “smells of open disobedience to the court and an illegal attempt to circumvent its precedents.”

However, Linton has another complaint about the 6-week ban in Texas, which is shared by many in the movement: it does not go far enough. A better way for states, he argues, is to pass “provocative laws” that ban all abortions at any stage of pregnancy unless they cancel them against Wade.

“An abortion ban bill only after an unborn child has a noticeable heartbeat is an unprincipled step back from the comprehensive protection that all unborn children deserve,” he wrote.

States impose 15-week abortion ban as right-wingers debate Roe’s next strategy

Source link States impose 15-week abortion ban as right-wingers debate Roe’s next strategy

Back to top button