Health

POLITICO-Harvard Poll: Majority of Americans Support Deportation of Migrants under Title 42

The Biden administration has come under fire from Republican lawmakers and many Democrats after the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention gave the order. Announced to end this monthCites improved public health conditions and access to vaccines and treatments.

Critics say the government is not ready to deal with the increase in migrants that the completion of the order might bring. The Department of Homeland Security said it prepares for up to 18,000 migrants daily when the order is completed.

More than 20 states have signed a legal challenge to continue the deportation of migrants in a Louisiana court, saying the CDC did not follow the proper procedure for completing the order and could not consider the impact of their decision on the states. A judge appointed by Trump on Friday ruled in their favor and issued a preliminary injunction not to complete the order.

The fact that so many Americans also support the use of public health measures to curb non-pandemic immigration ultimately reflects legislators’ failures in immigration reform, said Robert Blendon, Professor of Health Policy and Political Analysis, Emeritus. At the Har Chan School of Public Health at Harvard.

“They are taking something that is used to control epidemics and fighting for it because they know there is no way to reach an agreement on immigration,” he said. “Congress does not agree on what to do, and they are using the fig leaf as a public health emergency.”

The survey findings suggest that individuals’ support for maintaining order is informed by both their attitudes towards immigration and their political affiliation.

Among those who said they thought there should be less immigration in the United States, resistance to the termination order increased to 77 percent, while 72 percent of people who support more immigration think the order should end. 81 percent of Republicans oppose the completion of the title 42, compared to only 36 percent of Democrats.

Since Title 42 first came into force in March 2020, there have been more than 1.7 million expulsions under the policy, making public health law a de facto immigration control mechanism during a pandemic in both the Trump and Biden administrations.

Immigration advocates say the use of warrants to deport migrants is illegal, denying people fleeing persecution or torture the right to seek asylum in the United States, which is guaranteed under international humanitarian law. Jet than 10,200 people deported to Mexico According to the first human rights law, they were abducted, raped, tortured or violently attacked.

On March 4, a panel of three judges in the DC District Court unanimously ruled that the CDC could use the title to deport 42 migrant families – but not in jeopardy if they were not allowed to seek protection. While the Louisiana court ruling now prevents the completion of Title 42, Lee Gellert, chief attorney in the DC case, said the DC District Court order would prevent it from being used to persecute or torture migrant families.

Public health experts have long argued that the measure has little to do with the distribution of Covid-19 in the U.S. – and may in fact increase the risk of transmission, as policies have encouraged migrants to try to enter the country several times, increasing their movement.

According to the Institute for Migration Policy, in 2021, according to the Institute for Migration Policy, migrants did not stop trying to enter the United States with a record number of migrants, many migrants being allowed to enter due in part to unequal application of the policy. For example, under Title 42, more single adults have been expelled than families, and the administration will not expel accompanying children after November 2020.

Public health experts say the politicization of these policies threatens the effectiveness of public health mandates in future crises.

Health officials “are really concerned that when they use these kinds of powers, it should not be considered a political influence – it just stops the flow of disease,” said Blendon of Harvard.

The next time they need to use US border controls to stop the epidemic, “People will say, ‘No, you have a real political reason.’ You are against the Middle East, South America, Africa. “It has nothing to do with the disease, it has to do with your politics.”

POLITICO-Harvard Poll: Majority of Americans Support Deportation of Migrants under Title 42

Source link POLITICO-Harvard Poll: Majority of Americans Support Deportation of Migrants under Title 42

Back to top button